An Assessment of the Predictive Validity of Impact Factor Scores: Implications for Academic Employment Decisions in Social Work  

Oleh:

Holden, Gary ; Rosenberg, Gary ; Barker, Kathleen ; Onghena, Patrick

Jenis: Article from Journal - e-Journal
Dalam koleksi: Research on Social Work Practice vol. 16 no. 6 (Nov. 2006), page 613-624.
Topik: scientific communication; decision making; personnel promotion; personnel selection; teacher tenure; educational personnel; occupational tenure; career development; higher education; citation analysis; impact factor scores; validity; faculty; hiring; reappointment; social work education
Fulltext: 613.pdf (115.31KB)

Isi artikel

Objective: Bibliometrics is a method of examining scholarly communications. Concerns regarding the use of bibliometrics in general, and the impact factor score (IFS) in particular, have been discussed across disciplines including social work. Although there are frequent mentions in the literature of the IFS as an indicator of the impact or quality of scholars’ work, little empirical work has been published regarding the validity of such use. Method: A proportionate, stratified, random sample, of n = 323 articles was selected from 17 Web of Science listed social work journals published during the 1992 to 1994 period. Results: The relationship between journals’ IFSs and the actual impact of articles published in those journals (predictive validity) was r = .41 (short term) and r = .42 (long term). Conclusion: The practice of using the IFS as a proxy indicator of article impact merits significant concern as well as further empirical investigation.

Opini Anda

Klik untuk menuliskan opini Anda tentang koleksi ini!

Kembali