"Getting Gut-Level": Punishment, Gender, and Therapeutic Governance  

Oleh:

McKim, Allison

Jenis: Article from Journal - ilmiah internasional
Dalam koleksi: Gender and society; vol. 22 no. 03 (Jun. 2008), page 303-323.
Topik: governance; gender; punishment; alternatives to incarceration; therapeutic programs
Fulltext: 303.pdf (119.19KB)

Isi artikel

Using ethnographic data gathered at a mandated, community-based drug treatment program for women offenders, this article analyzes how gendered notions of the self and of autonomy shape penal governance. This study examines how psychological models of women’s deviance, racialized visions of motherhood, and therapeutic techniques of the self come into tension with expectations of responsible, autonomous citizenship. The program prioritized therapeutic ways of governing its clients over those that emphasized economic self-reliance, rational decision making, and normalizing gender. This is because staff attributed criminal and addictive behaviors to women’s inadequate self-understanding and lack of emotional autonomy in personal relations. Staff discouraged women’s motherhood and paid labor because they saw these external obligations as a threat to women’s autonomous selfhood. This research complicates claims that contemporary forms of penal treatment manage offenders through rational incentives and personal responsibility by pointing to the ways that subject formation is a gendered process.

Opini Anda

Klik untuk menuliskan opini Anda tentang koleksi ini!

Kembali